-
Inventory:
1 In Stock
- Product ID: 17305
Checkout
The Indian Head Cent 1886 Extra Fine (Variety I) is a fascinating and desirable piece of late 19th-century American numismatics, representing a transitional year in the long-running Indian Head cent series. First introduced in 1859 and struck until 1909, the Indian Head cent was one of the most iconic and widely circulated small-denomination coins in the United States. The year 1886 is of particular interest to collectors because it produced two distinct obverse varieties, commonly referred to as Variety I and Variety II. Variety I, the earlier of the two, carries over the familiar obverse design used from 1880 through early 1886 and is distinguishable by specific design features, making it a highly collectible type for specialists and enthusiasts alike.
The Indian Head cent was designed by James Barton Longacre, Chief Engraver of the U.S. Mint. His design featured Liberty wearing a Native American feathered war bonnet—an artistic blend of neoclassical allegory and indigenous symbolism. Though often assumed to depict a Native American figure, the portrait is actually that of Liberty, embodying the spirit of the nation in a distinctly American style. The coin was well received by the public and remained in production for half a century. Its enduring popularity can be attributed to its simple yet powerful imagery and its presence during a period of intense economic, technological, and social change in the United States.
The obverse of the 1886 Indian Head cent (Variety I) displays the traditional image of Liberty facing left, wearing a detailed feathered headdress inscribed with the word “LIBERTY.” Surrounding the portrait are the inscriptions “UNITED STATES” to the left and “OF AMERICA” to the right. The date “1886” appears centered below the bust. The key distinguishing feature of Variety I lies in the last feather of the headdress, which points between the “I” and “C” of “AMERICA.” This stands in contrast to Variety II, where the feather points between the “C” and “A.” The alignment of the feather is the primary diagnostic used by collectors to identify the two obverses. In Extra Fine condition, the obverse retains considerable sharpness and clarity, with visible detail across Liberty’s face, headdress, and the surrounding inscriptions.
The reverse of the coin maintains the same design used throughout most of the Indian Head cent series: a laurel wreath encircling the denomination “ONE CENT,” topped by a small Union shield. The wreath is symbolic of honor and strength, while the shield emphasizes national unity and resilience. This design was first introduced in 1860 and remained in place through the end of the series in 1909. On a coin graded Extra Fine, the reverse design shows light to moderate wear on the high points of the wreath and shield, but most of the leaf detail and the overall structure of the reverse remain bold and easily discernible. The central “ONE CENT” inscription remains strong and well-centered.
The 1886 Indian Head cents were all struck at the Philadelphia Mint, as no branch mints produced one-cent coins during this period. Consequently, none of the 1886 coins bear a mintmark. The coin was struck in the post-1864 bronze alloy consisting of 95% copper and 5% tin and zinc. This composition, lighter and easier to strike than the earlier copper-nickel alloy, allowed for finer detail and improved die life. Bronze Indian Head cents typically weigh 3.11 grams and measure 19 millimeters in diameter. The alloy also lends itself to a wide range of natural toning, from bright red-brown in higher grades to deep chocolate brown in more circulated examples.
The total mintage for 1886 Indian Head cents was 17,650,000 coins. However, this number encompasses both Variety I and Variety II, and the precise distribution between the two varieties is not definitively known. It is widely believed among numismatists that Variety I was struck earlier in the year, making up the minority of the total production. As a result, the 1886 Variety I cent is scarcer than its counterpart and commands a premium in collector markets. This scarcity is especially apparent in higher circulated grades like Extra Fine, where detail is still strong but prices remain more accessible than uncirculated examples.
In Extra Fine (XF) condition, the 1886 Variety I Indian Head cent presents a pleasing combination of historical character and preserved design elements. On the obverse, Liberty’s cheek, jawline, and the high points of her headdress show modest wear, but her eye, nose, and chin remain sharp. The word “LIBERTY” on the headband is usually mostly legible, with four to six letters visible. The feather lines are clear, and the alignment of the final feather—a key diagnostic for Variety I—is easily observed between the “I” and “C” of “AMERICA.” The date is fully struck and centered, and the rim is typically bold and complete.
The reverse shows similar quality, with defined wreath leaves and a distinct Union shield. While the bow tying the wreath may show some wear, it remains fully outlined. The “ONE CENT” inscription is bold and centrally located, making the coin’s identity immediately clear. A high-quality XF example will have smooth, even wear with no major nicks, corrosion, or cleaning damage. Natural color for this grade ranges from medium brown to dark chocolate, with occasional hints of red-brown in protected areas. Some collectors prize subtle woodgrain toning—a product of the bronze alloy’s copper mixture—which can enhance visual appeal and uniqueness.
The surface quality of an Extra Fine 1886 Variety I cent is an important factor in its value. Clean, problem-free coins with attractive patina are always in demand, especially among those working on full-date or variety sets of the Indian Head cent series. Because this variety can be overlooked by casual collectors unfamiliar with the feather diagnostic, well-identified specimens often sell quickly. Numismatists who focus on die varieties or transitional years especially appreciate the 1886 Variety I for its role in bridging the design elements used throughout the 1880s with the subtle revisions that would lead into the later Indian Head years of the 1890s.
The 1886 Indian Head Cent Variety I in Extra Fine condition is a historical and artistic gem. Its significance as a scarce variety, coupled with its late-19th-century production during a time of industrial growth and national transformation, makes it an essential addition to any serious U.S. coin collection. With sharp design detail, pleasing surfaces, and clear diagnostics, it offers collectors an opportunity to own a meaningful and beautiful coin that captures the spirit of a bygone era. Whether collected as part of a complete Indian Head set, a type set, or for its individual rarity, the 1886 Variety I cent in Extra Fine condition continues to hold its place as a respected and valuable piece of American numismatic heritage.